• Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Davis+Gilbert LLP

From our base in New York, we represent a diverse range of clients across the country and around the world.

  • People
  • Services
  • Emerging Issues
Insights + Events
bookmarkprintShare>

Alert - November 20, 2026

New York Limits Employee Stay or Pay Agreements Under the Trapped at Work Act

The Bottom Line

  • Effective December 19, 2026, New York employers are generally prohibited from requiring stay-or-pay agreements from employees who leave before a specified time period.
  • Signing bonus repayment agreements are still permissible, with certain limitations.
  • Noncompliance carries real cost – violators may be fined.

Effective December 19, 2026, the Trapped at Work Act (the “Act”) generally bans New York employers from requiring, as a condition of employment, any employee or prospective employee to sign an employment promissory note.

With certain exceptions, the Act applies to any agreement or contract provision requiring an employee to pay the employer money if the employee’s employment relationship ends before a stated period of time has passed (commonly known as a “stay or pay” agreement). Importantly, traditional sign-on bonuses that require repayment if an employee leaves early are generally not prohibited, as long as certain requirements are met.

What Employers Can Still Require

The Act does not prohibit all agreements that require employees to repay money to their employers. Instead, it preserves several common arrangements, provided certain conditions are met. These include:

  • Certain education and credential costs. Employers may require the employee to reimburse the costs of tuition, fees, and educational materials for a “transferable credential” if the agreement (i) is in a separate written contract, (ii) does not require the employee to obtain the transferable credential as a condition of employment, (iii) specifies the repayment amount, which does not exceed the actual costs to the employer, (iv) provides for prorated repayment during any required employment period, and (v) does not require repayment to the employer by the employee if the employee is terminated, except if terminated for misconduct.
  • Voluntary purchases or leases. Employers may require the employee to pay for any property the employer has sold or leased to them, as long as such sale or lease was voluntary.
  • Certain bonuses and incentives. Employers may require the employee to repay a financial bonus, relocation assistance, or other non-educational incentive or other payment or benefit that is not tied to specific job performance. However, repayment generally cannot be required if the employee was terminated for any reason other than misconduct or the duties or requirements of the job were misrepresented to the employee.
  • Sabbatical arrangements for educational personnel. Educational personnel may still be required to comply with any terms or conditions of sabbatical leave granted by their employers.
  • Collectively bargained arrangements. The Act also permits agreements entered as part of a program agreed to by the employer and its employees’ collective bargaining representative.

What Is a “Transferable Credential”?

For purposes of the exemptions, a “transferable credential” is any degree, diploma, license, certificate, or course completion documentation that is widely recognized by employers within the relevant industry or provides skills or qualifications that improve an employee’s ability to find employment elsewhere.

However, a “transferable credential” does not include (i) employer-specific or non-transferable training, such as training on an employer’s proprietary systems, internal policies, or proprietary equipment unique to the employer, or instruction that does not qualify the employee for a new occupational title, and (ii) mandated safety and compliance training.

Unenforceable Agreements, Fee Shifting and Fines

Under the Act, a prohibited promissory note is unconscionable and unenforceable. However, if the prohibited provision is part of a larger agreement, the other provisions of the agreement will not be affected.

Employers may also face additional consequences for attempting to enforce a prohibited promissory note. If an employer sues an employee based on a prohibited promissory note, the employee can recover their attorney’s fees upon a successful defense.

Further, an employee or prospective employee aggrieved by a violation may also file complaints with the New York State Department of Labor (“NYDOL”). The NYDOL may fine violators between $1,000 and $5,000 per employee or prospective employee who has an agreement that violates the Act.

Key Takeaways from the NYDOL Guidance

The NYDOL recently issued guidance that addresses several practical questions about the Act, including who is covered, when the Act applies and what types of repayment arrangements may remain permissible. Key clarifications include:

  • Coverage is broad. All private and public sector employers in New York State, and all employees (regardless of full-time, part-time, or seasonal employee status), are covered by the Act. However, the guidance does not clarify what relationship the employee must have to New York to be covered.
  • A transferable credential must have value outside the employer. In practical terms, the credential must make the employee marketable to other employers, rather than provide skills or training useful only to the current employer.
  • Truly voluntary agreements may fall outside the Act. The Act does not apply (i) if the agreement was voluntary and separate from maintaining or accepting employment, meaning that the employee could continue with employment without agreeing to the terms, or (ii) to agreements that are expressly allowed or required under statute or common law, such as lawful wage advances.
  • NYDOL interprets “misconduct” broadly. As used in the Act, “misconduct” means behavior that is detrimental to the employer’s interests or in violation of some reasonable work condition, including what an employer’s policy may define as “for cause” in a termination decision.
  • The Act is prospective. It applies only to new agreements, or new or amended terms in existing agreements, entered into on or after December 19, 2026; and
  • There is no express private right of action for an employee; the NYDOL is the enforcement entity.

How These Rules Apply in Practice

The NYDOL also provided some examples of non-educational agreements that do and do not violate the Act. For example:

  • If an employee accepts a signing bonus and resigns before an agreed-upon date, repayment may be required because the employer did not terminate the relationship, the employee did.
  • If an employee accepts a signing bonus and their employer fires them for misconduct before an agreed-upon date, repayment may be required because the employee was terminated for misconduct.
  • If an employee accepts a signing bonus and their employer eliminates their position before an agreed-upon date, repayment cannot be required because the employee was terminated for a reason other than misconduct.
  • If an employee accepts a signing bonus and their employee resigns before an agreed-upon date because their employer misled the employee about the job requirements, then repayment cannot be required because the employee was misled about the job.
  • If an employer offers their employee the option to receive an up-front payment that is contingent on meeting specified performance targets, then repayment may be required, so long as the employee also has the option to defer the contingent payment until after meeting such performance targets. In that circumstance, accepting the up-front payment was not a condition of employment.
  • If an employer agrees to advance paid leave time to an employee and the employee leaves before an agreed-upon date when leave is earned repayment may be required because accepting the advance was not a condition of employment.

Employers that use repayment provisions should review the terms of those agreements in light of the Act and the NYDOL guidance, particularly when entering into new agreements or amending existing ones on or after December 19, 2026.

Primary Sidebar

Related People

  • Partner Greg Brochin

    Gregg Brochin

    Partner

    Area Of Focus

    • Labor + Employment
    212 468 4950
    gbrochin@dglaw.com
  • View All

Related Services

  • Labor + Employment

Get the latest insights from Davis+Gilbert

Subscribe
  • Sitemap
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Accessibility Statement
  • About Us
  • Location
  • Subscribe
© 2026 Copyright Davis+Gilbert LLP. Attorney Advertising.
  • People
  • Services
  • Emerging Issues
  • Insights + Events
  • Culture + Community
  • Pro Bono + Corporate Social Responsibility
  • Careers
  • About Us
  • Subscribe
  • Blogs
  • Location
This site uses cookies from third party providers for them to collect and store information from and on your device. These cookies either support essential functions of the site or are used to develop analytics regarding usage of our site. Click Accept to continue using the site with our recommended settings or click Decline to disable non-essential cookies. See our Privacy Policy for more information.